| Cedarville University Athletic Hall of Fame |
| 2000 | | Bill Boulet (athlete) |
| 2001 | | Mark Womack (athlete) |
| 2003 | | Tim Birk (athlete) |
| | | |
| NAIA District 22 Medalists |
| 1975 | | Doug Burke |
| 1979 | | Mark Womack |
| 1990 | | Ryan Bowen |
| | | |
| Mid-Ohio Conference Medalists |
| 1975 | | Doug Burke |
| 1978 | | Tim Birk |
| 1982 | | Bill Boulet |
| 1983 | | John Greenwood |
| | | |
| NCCAA Midwest Region Medalists |
| 1981 | | Mark Womack |
| 1982 | | Mark Womack |
| 1985 | | Tom Greve |
| | | |
| NAIA All-America Scholar-Athletes |
| 1998 | | Steve Burchett |
| 2000 | | Russ Toms |
| 2001 | | Russ Toms |
| 2002 | | Tom Simon |
| 2003 | | Tom Simon |
| | | |
| NCCAA All-America Scholar-Athletes |
| 2002 | | Tom Simon |
| 2003 | | Tom Simon |
| | | |
| NAIA District 22 Coach of the Year |
| 1979 | | Allen Monroe |
| 1981 | | Allen Monroe |
| | | |
| Mid-Ohio Conference Coach of the Year |
| 1984 | | Allen Monroe |
| | | |
| All-NAIA District 22 |
| 1970 | | Jim Buzzard (73-32-105; 27 holes) |
| 1975 | | Doug Burke (70-31-101; 3-under; 27 holes)* |
| 1978 | | Tim Birk (73-37-110; 27 holes) |
| 1979 | | Mark Womack (75-32-107; 27 holes)* |
| | | Keith Rice (78-30-108) |
| 1980 | | Mark Womack (73-36-109; 27 holes) |
| 1981 | | Brian Johnson (77-75-152) |
| | | Bill Boulet (76-78-154) |
| 1982 | | Bill Boulet (69-40-109, 27 holes) |
| | | Mark Womack (74-36-110) |
| | | Brian Johnson (74-39-113) |
| 1983 | | Tom Ewing (77-79-156) |
| 1984 | | Tom Ewing (76-78-154) |
| | | Mike Reed (74-83-157) |
| 1985 | | Mark Reed (78-75-153) |
| 1987 | | Mark Reed (74-76-150) |
| 1990 | | Ryan Bowen (78-77-155)* |
| 1991 | | Ryan Bowen (81-81-162) |
| * Medalist | | |
| | | |
| All-American Mideast Conference |
| 2002 | | Craig Bennington (78-75-73-226) |
| 2005 | | Adam Schlappi (79-71-74-224) |
| | | |
| All-Mid-Ohio Conference |
| 1970 | | Jim Buzzard |
| 1971 | | Jim Buzzard* |
| 1975 | | Doug Burke*, Dave Slusher |
| 1976 | | Jon Wyman |
| 1978 | | Tim Birk* |
| 1979 | | Dave Ellis |
| 1981 | | Bill Boulet, Brian Johnson |
| 1982 | | Bill Boulet* |
| 1983 | | John Greenwood* |
| 1984 | | Tom Ewing, Mike Reed |
| 1985 | | Mark Reed |
| 1990 | | Ryan Bowen, Dan Schearer |
| *Medalist | | |
| | | |
| All-NCCAA Midwest Region |
| 1981 | | Mark Womack (78)*, Bill Boulet (79), Brian Johnson (79) |
| 1982 | | Mark Womack (72)*, Brian Johnson (74), John Greenwood (74), Tom Ewing (76) |
| 1983 | | Tom Ewing (77), Mike Reed (78) |
| 1984 | | Tom Ewing (75), Mike Reed (77) |
| 1985 | | Tom Greve (77)*, Mark Reed (77), Bob Fires (79), Dave Kalin (79) |
| 1988 | | Dan Schearer (75), Ryan Bowen (76), Mark Reed (77) |
| 1990 | | Brian Blackburn (77), Dan Schearer (77), Sean Cannone (79) |
| 1991 | | Dan Schearer (78) |
| 1992 | | Ted Kruse (78) |
| 1994 | | Kevin Belmont (83), Jeff Gaglio (83) |
| *Medalist | | |
