| Year | | Team Champion | | Ced. | | Individual Champion | | Cedarville |
| 1991 | | Indiana Wesleyan | | 2nd | | Ryan Sommers (Indiana Wesleyan), 25:00 | | Kevin Conkel (4th, 25:36) |
| 1992 | | Indiana Wesleyan | | 2nd | | Peter Casaletto (Cedarville), 25:42 | | Casaletto |
| 1993 | | Indiana Wesleyan | | 2nd | | Peter Simons (Cedarville), 26:03 | | Simons |
| 1994 | | Taylor | | 3rd | | James Njoroge (Taylor), 24:34 | | Peter Simons (6th, 26:17) |
| 1995 | | Taylor | | 2nd | | James Njoroge (Taylor), 24:52 | | Eric Crawford (5th, 26:02) |
| 1996 | | Taylor | | 2nd | | James Njoroge (Taylor), 24:42 | | Eric Crawford (10th, 26:17) |
| 1997 | | Cedarville | | 1st | | Dan Denning (Kenyon), 25:39 | | Ben Thompson (3rd, 25:45) |
| 1998 | | Taylor | | 3rd | | Kip Rop (Taylor), 24:57 | | Jody Fox (7th, 26:14) |
| 1999 | | Taylor | | 4th | | Kip Rop (Taylor), 25:01 | | Steve Wakefield (13th, 26:17) |
| 2000 | | Kenyon | | 2nd | | Daniel Njenga (Grace), 25:44 | | Sergio Reyes (2nd, 25:47) |
| 2001 | | Kenyon | | 4th | | Ben Hudebrand (Kenyon), 25:46 | | Josh Mark (7th, 26:14) |
| 2002 | | Cedarville | | 1st | | Sergio Reyes (Cedarville), 24:46 | | Reyes |
| 2003 | | Wright State | | 3rd | | Dan Campbell (Cedarville), 25:24 | | Campbell |
| 2004 | | Otterbein | | 3rd | | Mike Sawicki (Otterbein), 25:06 | | Dan Campbell (5th, 25:30) |
| 2005 | | Ohio State | | 4th | | Julius Rono (Roberts Wesleyan), 24:45 | | Kevi nHall (18th, 26:12) |
