| 2000 - Head Coach: Sue Carpenter | | 24-15 (.615) Overall; 15-9 (.625) AMC* | | OHIO WESLEYAN | | L | | 2-3 | | OHIO WESLEYAN | | L | | 1-3 | | SAINT VINCENT* | | W | | 4-0 | | SAINT VINCENT* | | W | | 4-1 | | SETON HILL* | | W | | 10-0 | | SETON HILL* | | W | | 14-6 | | OHIO DOMINICAN* | | L | | 0-2 | | OHIO DOMINICAN* | | L | | 0-9 | | MOUNT VERNON NAZARENE* | | W | | 2-1 (8) | | MOUNT VERNON NAZARENE* | | L | | 1-7 | | at Shawnee State* | | W | | 6-2 | | at Shawnee State* | | L | | 3-11 | | at Tiffin* | | L | | 0-4 | | at Tiffin* | | L | | 3-5 | | WILMINGTON | | W | | 8-0 | | WILMINGTON | | W | | 11-3 | | WALSH* | | W | | 1-0 | | WALSH* | | L | | 0-1 (8) | | MALONE* | | W | | 3-1 | | MALONE* | | W | | 7-5 | | at Notre Dame OH* | | W | | 4-3 | | at Notre Dame OH* | | L | | 3-4 | | | | | | | | NCCAA Midwest Regional; Marion, IN | | Grace | | W | | 3-2 | | at Indiana Wesleyan | | W | | 6-1 | | Concordia | | W | | 4-3 (8) | | Spring Arbor | | W | | 6-2 | | | | | | | | RIO GRANDE* | | W | | 2-1 | | RIO GRANDE* | | L | | 1-2 | | | | | | | | NCCAA National Tournament; Marion, IN | | East Texas Baptist | | L | | 0-1 (8) | | Oakland City | | L | | 2-4 | | | | | | | | GENEVA* | | W | | 5-3 | | GENEVA* | | W | | 5-3 | | URBANA* | | W | | 9-2 | | URBANA* | | W | | 13-0 | | | | | | | | NAIA Region IX Tournament; North Canton, OH | | Shawnee State | | W | | 3-2 (8) | | at Walsh | | L | | 4-5 | | Tiffin | | W | | 3-2 | | College of West Virginia | | W | | 5-0 | | Ohio Dominican | | L | | 1-2 | | | 2001 - Head Coach: Sue Carpenter | | 18-18 (.500) Overall; 11-13 (.458) AMC* | | at Warner Southern | | L | | 1-9 | | at Warner Southern | | L | | 0-2 | | at Webber | | W | | 1-0 | | at Webber | | L | | 1-2 | | OHIO WESLEYAN | | W | | 3-0 | | OHIO WESLEYAN | | W | | 9-1 | | at Malone* | | L | | 1-4 | | at Malone* | | L | | 1-9 | | at Walsh* | | L | | 1-9 | | at Walsh* | | L | | 0-8 | | SHAWNEE STATE* | | L | | 2-4 | | SHAWNEE STATE* | | L | | 0-6 | | RIO GRANDE* | | W | | 5-3 | | RIO GRANDE* | | L | | 2-5 | | GENEVA* | | W | | 6-5 (10) | | GENEVA* | | L | | 6-9 | | POINT PARK* | | W | | 9-0 | | POINT PARK (forfeit) | | W | | 7-0 | | NOTRE DAME OH* | | W | | 8-0 | | NOTRE DAME OH* | | W | | 6-2 | | URBANA* | | W | | 6-4 (10) | | URBANA* | | L | | 5-13 | | at Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | W | | 6-0 | | at Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 10-12 | | | | | | | | NCCAA Midwest Regional; Cedarville | | INDIANA WESLEYAN | | W | | 3-1 (8) | | SPRING ARBOR | | W | | 6-0 | | INDIANA WESLEYAN | | L | | 1-2 (8) | | INDIANA WESLEYAN | | L | | 1-4 | | | | | | | | at Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 0-1 (10) | | at Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 1-7 | | TIFFIN* | | W | | 1-0 | | TIFFIN* | | L | | 4-9 | | at Saint Vincent* | | W | | 3-0 | | at Saint Vincent* | | W | | 7-3 | | at Seton Hill* | | W | | 12-1 | | at Seton Hill* | | W | | 9-4 | |
| | |
| 2002 - Head Coach: Sue Carpenter | | 30-22 (.577) Overall; 19-9 (.679) AMC* | | Sun West Tournament; Orange, CA | | Whitworth | | W | | 14-5 | | Plattsburgh State | | L | | 3-6 | | | | | | | | at Master's | | L | | 3-7 | | at Master's | | L | | 2-8 | | | | | | | | Sun West Tournament; Orange, CA | | Wisconsin-LaCrosse | | L | | 0-5 | | Grace | | W | | 5-0 | | Plattsburgh State | | L | | 1-5 | | Redlands | | W | | 1-0 | | | | | | | | MALONE* | | L | | 2-5 | | MALONE* | | W | | 3-2 | | at Denison | | L | | 0-3 | | at Denison | | L | | 2-4 | | SAINT VINCENT* | | W | | 5-2 | | SAINT VINCENT* | | W | | 8-0 | | SETON HILL* | | W | | 6-1 | | SETON HILL* | | W | | 10-5 | | WILMINGTON | | W | | 1-0 | | WILMINGTON | | W | | 2-1 | | at Urbana* | | L | | 3-4 | | at Urbana* | | W | | 10-1 | | at Shawnee State* | | L | | 1-5 | | at Shawnee State* | | W | | 6-2 | | CARLOW* | | W | | 6-0 | | CARLOW* | | W | | 9-1 | | at Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | W | | 8-1 | | at Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 5-7 | | GENEVA* | | W | | 5-0 | | GENEVA* | | W | | 6-2 | | | | | | | | NCCAA Midwest Regional; Spring Arbor, MI | | Concordia | | W | | 2-1 | | Indiana Wesleyan | | L | | 4-9 | | at Spring Arbor | | W | | 3-2 | | Indiana Wesleyan | | L | | 2-4 | | | | | | | | TIFFIN* | | W | | 6-1 | | TIFFIN* | | L | | 1-2 | | | | | | | | NCCAA National Tournament; Marion, IN | | Mid-Continent | | L | | 2-10 | | Louisiana | | W | | 2-1 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 0-1 | | | | | | | | at Rio Grande* | | W | | 6-0 | | at Rio Grande* | | L | | 1-7 | | at Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 0-2 | | at Ohio Dominican* | | W | | 4-3 | | at Notre Dame OH* | | W | | 7-6 | | at Notre Dame OH* | | W | | 4-3 | | at Walsh* | | L | | 3-4 (9) | | at Walsh* | | L | | 5-7 | | at Point Park* | | W | | 16-1 | | at Point Park* | | W | | 5-0 | | | | | | | | NAIA Region IX Tournament; Columbus, OH | | Urbana | | W | | 3-2 | | at Ohio Dominican | | L | | 0-4 | | Walsh | | W | | 2-1 | | Malone | | L | | 2-3 | | | 2003 - Head Coach: Sue Carpenter | | 14-22 (.389) Overall; 7-9 (.438) AMC South* | | MOUNT VERNON NAZARENE | | W | | 3-1 | | MOUNT VERNON NAZARENE | | L | | 1-4 | | at Master's | | L | | 0-1 | | at Master's | | L | | 0-4 | | at California Lutheran (8 inn.) | | L | | 2-3 | | at California Lutheran | | W | | 4-3 | | | | | | | | Sun West Tournament; Orange, CA | | Point Loma Nazarene | | L | | 0-8 | | California Baptist | | L | | 5-6 | | Luther | | W | | 6-0 | | Eastern Oregon | | L | | 0-9 | | LaVerne | | L | | 1-7 | | California Lutheran | | L | | 1-5 | | | | | | | | URBANA* | | W | | 1-0 | | URBANA* | | W | | 5-1 | | NOTRE DAME OH | | W | | 8-0 | | NOTRE DAME OH | | W | | 8-3 | | RIO GRANDE* | | W | | 8-6 | | RIO GRANDE* | | L | | 2-9 | | at Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 3-8 | | at Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 2-5 | | at Urbana* | | W | | 2-1 | | at Urbana* | | L | | 0-5 | | SHAWNEE STATE* | | W | | 7-0 | | SHAWNEE STATE* | | L | | 0-1 (13) | | | | | | | | NCCAA Midwest Regional; Winona Lake, IN | | Spring Arbor | | L | | 0-3 | | at Grace | | W | | 2-0 | | Concordia | | W | | 8-0 | | Indiana Wesleyan | | L | | 0-6 | | | | | | | | at Shawnee State* | | L | | 1-3 | | at Shawnee State* | | W | | 6-2 | | at Rio Grande* | | L | | 2-3 (18) | | at Rio Grande* | | W | | 3-0 | | OHIO DOMINICAN* | | L | | 10-14 (11) | | OHIO DOMINICAN* | | L | | 0-3 | | | | | | | | American Mideast Conference Qualifier | | at Tiffin | | L | | 0-2 | | at Tiffin | | L | | 2-5 | |
| | |
| | |
| 2004 - Head Coach: Sue Carpenter | | 27-15 (.643) Overall; 8-6 (.571) AMC South* | | Cumberland Classic; Lebanon, TN | | Cumberland KY | | W | | 7-0 | | Cumberland KY | | W | | 9-4 | | at Cumberland TN | | L | | 1-2 | | at Cumberland TN | | W | | 2-0 | | | | | | | | Gene Cusic Classic; Fort Myers, FL | | Aquinas | | W | | 2-1 | | Saint Ambrose | | L | | 3-4 | | Cornerstone | | W | | 1-0 | | Robert Morris IL | | W | | 5-0 | | Bridgeport | | W | | 2-0 | | Central Methodist | | L | | 3-6 | | Assumption | | L | | 1-2 | | Cornerstone | | L | | 3-8 | | Saint Thomas | | W | | 3-0 | | Saint Lawrence | | W | | 9-5 | | | | | | | | TIFFIN | | L | | 2-3 | | TIFFIN | | W | | 2-1 | | at Findlay | | L | | 3-4 | | at Findlay | | W | | 4-0 | | GENEVA | | W | | 1-0 | | GENEVA | | W | | 4-0 | | RIO GRANDE* | | W | | 2-0 | | RIO GRANDE* | | W | | 6-5 | | NOTRE DAME OH | | W | | 5-0 | | NOTRE DAME OH | | W | | 6-1 | | at Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 0-2 | | at Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 1-13 | | SHAWNEE STATE* | | W | | 4-1 | | SHAWNEE STATE* | | L | | 1-6 | | MALONE* | | W | | 1-0 | | MALONE* | | W | | 4-1 | | at Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 1-2 | | at Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 2-3 | | at Urbana* | | W | | 6-1 | | at Urbana* | | L | | 0-1 | | | | | | | | NCCAA Midwest Regional; Cedarville | | CONCORDIA | | W | | 4-0 | | SPRING ARBOR | | L | | 1-2 | | CONCORDIA | | W | | 2-1 | | INDIANA WESLEYAN | | L | | 0-1 | | | | | | | | WALSH* | | W | | 4-0 | | WALSH* (forfeit) | | W | | 7-0 | | at Point Park | | W | | 11-0 | | at Point Park | | W | | 8-0 | | | 2005 - Head Coach: Sue Carpenter | | 27-15 (.643) Overall; 10-4 (.714) AMC South* | | Cumberland Classic; Lebanon, TN | | at Cumberland TN | | L | | 2-10 | | at Cumberland TN | | W | | 3-0 | | Mountain State | | L | | 1-2 | | Mountain State | | W | | 9-6 | | | | | | | | Gene Cusic Classic; Fort Myers, FL | | Madonna | | L | | 3-4 | | Geneva | | W | | 3-2 | | Bridgeport | | W | | 1-0 | | Robert Morris IL | | W | | 1-0 | | Cornerstone | | W | | 2-1 | | Saint Joseph's ME | | W | | 10-2 | | Aurora | | L | | 0-2 | | Saint Thomas | | W | | 2-1 (8) | | | | | | | | at Walsh* | | W | | 1-0 | | at Walsh* | | L | | 1-2 | | URBANA* | | W | | 8-0 | | URBANA* | | W | | 3-2 | | at Malone* | | W | | 5-1 | | at Malone* | | W | | 8-1 | | at Shawnee State* | | W | | 5-4 (13) | | at Shawnee State* | | W | | 4-3 | | at Rio Grande* | | W | | 5-3 | | at Rio Grande* | | L | | 1-3 | | SETON HILL | | W | | 9-1 | | SETON HILL | | W | | 9-1 | | at Tiffin | | L | | 2-4 | | at Tiffin | | L | | 1-4 | | MOUNT VERNON NAZARENE* | | W | | 5-3 | | MOUNT VERNON NAZARENE* | | W | | 2-1 | | FINDLAY | | W | | 7-2 | | FINDLAY | | W | | 2-1 (8) | | | | | | | | NCCAA Midwest Regional; Spring Arbor, MI | | at Spring Arbor | | L | | 4-6 | | Concordia | | W | | 6-4 (8) | | | | | | | | OHIO DOMINICAN* | | L | | 0-8 | | OHIO DOMINICAN* | | L | | 3-7 | | | | | | | | NCCAA National Tournament; Marion, IN | | Chowan | | L | | 0-3 | | Bethel | | L | | 2-5 | | | | | | | | American Mideast Conference Qualifier | | SETON HILL | | W | | 2-0 | | SETON HILL | | W | | 4-1 | | | | | | | | NAIA Region IX Tournament; Columbus, OH | | at Ohio Dominican | | L | | 2-4 | | Mountain State | | W | | 7-4 | | Urbana | | W | | 7-3 | | Tiffin | | L | | 1-4 | |
| | |
| | |
| | |
