| 1985 - Head Coach: Elaine Brown | | 15-9 (.625) Overall; 6-2 (.750) WBCC* | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 3-5 | | Mount St. Joseph | | W | | 11-8 | | Urbana* | | W | | 8-2 | | Urbana* | | W | | 9-5 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | W | | 4-1 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 1-5 | | Tiffin | | W | | 8-2 | | Tiffin | | W | | 12-8 | | Bluffton* | | W | | 11-4 | | Bluffton* | | W | | 13-1 | | Wilmington* | | L | | 9-13 | | Wilmington* | | W | | 9-6 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 5-2 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 13-6 | | Taylor | | L | | 10-17 | | Spring Arbor | | W | | 6-3 | | Findlay* | | W | | 5-4 | | Findlay* | | L | | 6-7 | | Marietta | | W | | 5-0 | | Marietta | | W | | 12-2 | | Western Buckeye Collegaite Conference Tournament | | Urbana | | L | | 9-10 | | Wilmington | | L | | 4-17 | | NAIA District 22 Tournament | | Findlay | | L | | 1-7 | | Walsh | | L | | 4-6 | | | 1986 - Head Coach: Mark Mathews | | 9-16 (.360) Overall; 3-7 (.300) WBCC* | | Bluffton* | | W | | 23-17 | | Bluffton* | | L | | 6-17 | | Ohio Dominican | | L | | 4-7 | | Ohio Dominican | | W | | 5-4 | | Urbana* | | W | | 5-4 | | Urbana* | | L | | 6-8 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 0-9 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 1-7 | | Defiance* | | L | | 1-5 | | Defiance* | | L | | 2-5 | | Earlham | | W | | 11-4 | | Earlham | | W | | 19-4 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 7-8 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 0-12 | | Wooster | | L | | 4-5 | | Wooster | | W | | 10-3 | | Wilmington* | | L | | 3-11 | | Wilmington* | | W | | 13-1 | | Mount St. Joseph | | W | | 7-5 | | Taylor | | L | | 4-7 | | Taylor | | L | | 2-7 | | Western Buckeye Collegiate Conference Tournament | | Urbana | | L | | 4-6 | | Tiffin | | L | | 8-9 | | | | | | | | Wittenberg | | L | | 2-8 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 5-2 | |
| | |
| 1987 - Head Coach: Mark Mathews | | 10-12-1 (.457) Overall; 2-8 (.200) WBCC* | | Ohio Dominican | | W | | 7-6 | | Ohio Dominican (10 inn.) | | L | | 10-11 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 3-4 | | Tiffin* | | W | | 8-1 | | Findlay* | | L | | 2-4 | | Findlay* | | L | | 4-13 | | Bluffton* | | W | | 2-0 | | Bluffton* | | L | | 4-8 | | Wilmington* | | L | | 3-4 | | Wilmington* | | L | | 9-10 | | Wilmington | | W | | 3-0 | | Defiance* | | L | | 0-8 | | Defiance* | | L | | 0-2 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene (12 inn.) | | L | | 1-2 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | T | | 7-7 | | Western Buckeye Collegiate Conference Tournament | | Wilmington | | W | | 9-2 | | Findlay | | L | | 1-3 | | Urbana | | W | | 7-2 | | Wilmington | | L | | 5-11 | | | | | | | | Taylor | | W | | 13-4 | | Taylor | | W | | 9-5 | | Earlham | | W | | 12-2 | | Earlham | | W | | 18-8 | | | 1988 - Head Coach: Bob Fires | | 14-11 (.560) Overall; 6-4 (.600) WBCC* | | Mount St. Joseph | | W | | 6-1 | | Mount St. Joseph | | W | | 12-6 | | Ohio Dominican | | L | | 3-7 | | Ohio Dominican | | L | | 0-9 | | Moun. Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 1-2 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 0-6 | | Bluffton* | | W | | 6-4 | | Bluffton* | | W | | 6-1 | | Tiffin* | | W | | 4-0 | | Tiffin* | | W | | 4-2 | | Findlay* | | L | | 4-9 | | Findlay* | | L | | 3-6 | | Wilmington* | | L | | 7-9 | | Wilmington* | | L | | 2-9 | | Capital | | W | | 6-1 | | Capital (8 inn.) | | W | | 2-1 | | Defiance* | | W | | 5-4 | | Defiance* | | W | | 9-3 | | Western Buckeye Collegiate Conference Tournament | | Tiffin | | W | | 4-3 | | Findlay | | L | | 0-16 | | Defiance | | L | | 2-6 | | | | | | | | Wittenberg (9 inn.) | | L | | 2-3 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 12-0 | | Urbana | | W | | 12-0 | | Urbana | | W | | 18-2 | |
| | |
| 1989 - Head Coach: Bob Fires | | 12-14 (.462) Overall; 5-3 (.625) WBCC* | | Grace | | L | | 6-7 | | Grace | | L | | 2-9 | | Huntington | | L | | 1-11 | | Huntington | | L | | 2-10 | | Urbana | | W | | 12-2 | | Wilmington* | | L | | 5-7 | | Wilmington* | | L | | 1-4 | | Bluffton* | | W | | 7-3 | | Bluffton* (8 inn.) | | L | | 3-4 | | Tiffin* | | W | | 7-4 | | Tiffin* | | W | | 6-1 | | Defiance* | | W | | 3-0 | | Defiance* | | W | | 8-2 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 0-11 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 3-4 | | Mount St.. Joseph | | W | | 15-8 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 1-4 | | Capital (12 inn.) | | W | | 4-3 | | Capital | | W | | 4-1 | | Shawnee State | | L | | 7-13 | | Shawnee State | | L | | 3-4 | | Western Buckeye Collegiate Conference Tournament | | Tiffin | | W | | 4-0 | | Findlay | | W | | 2-1 | | Wilmington | | L | | 0-6 | | Defiance (8 inn.) | | W | | 2-1 | | Wilmington | | L | | 2-4 | | |