Year-by-Year Results
(1990-1999)
| 1990 - Head Coach: Bob Fires | | 29-5 (.853) Overall; 6-0 (1.000) WBCC* | | Nyack | | W | | 11-0 | | Taylor | | W | | 3-0 | | Eastern | | W | | 11-0 | | Concordia | | W | | 14-2 | | Taylor | | W | | 4-2 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | W | | 1-0 | | Central Methodist | | W | | 3-1 | | Nyack | | W | | 13-3 | | Huntington | | W | | 5-0 | | Huntington (8 inn.) | | W | | 8-7 | | Ohio Dominican | | W | | 2-1 | | Ohio Dominican | | L | | 3-10 | | Findlay* | | W | | 16-3 | | Findlay* | | W | | 10-2 | | Urbana | | W | | 10-1 | | Shawnee State | | L | | 9-10 | | Shawnee State | | W | | 10-0 | | Wilmington* | | W | | 10-4 | | Wilmington* | | W | | 2-1 | | Tiffin | | W | | 7-2 | | Tiffin | | W | | 7-1 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 0-1 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene (8 inn.) | | W | | 1-0 | | Defiance* | | W | | 7-1 | | Defiance* | | W | | 8-0 | | Urbana | | W | | 18-3 | | Urbana | | W | | 15-2 | | Western Buckeye Collegiate Conference Tournament | | Bluffton | | W | | 4-3 | | Defiance | | W | | 3-0 | | Bluffton | | W | | 14-0 | | | | | | | | Wittenberg | | W | | 15-3 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 21-2 | | | | | | | | NAIA District 22 Tournament | | Tournament rained out; Cedarville, No. 1 seed, declared champion | | | | | | | | NAIA Bi-District 15 Playoff | | Aquinas | | L | | 1-2 | | Aquinas | | L | | 1-7 | | | 1991 - Head Coach: Chris Greenwood | | 8-19 (.296) Overall; 1-5 (.167) WBCC* | | Azusa Pacific | | L | | 1-7 | | Azusa Pacific | | L | | 4-5 | | Ohio Dominican | | L | | 1-2 | | Ohio Dominican | | L | | 1-11 | | Urbana | | W | | 21-3 | | Urbana | | L | | 4-11 | | Tiffin | | L | | 3-8 | | Tiffin | | L | | 1-3 | | Findlay* | | L | | 2-12 | | Findlay* | | L | | 4-8 | | Bluffton* | | L | | 3-7 | | Bluffton* | | L | | 6-8 | | Urbana | | W | | 11-5 | | Urbana | | L | | 3-4 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 0-7 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 0-15 | | Wilmington* | | L | | 3-7 | | Wilmington* | | W | | 13-6 | | Thomas More | | W | | 17-0 | | Thomas More | | W | | 17-1 | | Western Buckeye Collegiate Conference Tournament | | Defiance | | W | | 5-4 | | Findlay | | L | | 1-5 | | Bluffton | | L | | 10-21 | | | | | | | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 1-12 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 1-17 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 7-6 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 11-1 | |
| | |
| 1992 - Head Coach: Kathy Freese | | 11-16 (.407) Overall; 5-9 (.357) MOC* | | Culver-Stockton | | L | | 1-6 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 1-6 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 2-7 | | Malone | | L | | 8-12 | | Malone | | W | | 7-4 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 0-10 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 1-7 | | Findlay | | L | | 3-5 | | Findlay | | W | | 5-1 | | Rio Grande* | | L | | 4-5 | | Rio Grande* | | W | | 2-1 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 6-10 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 2-3 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 2-9 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 0-13 | | Wilmington | | L | | 4-5 | | Wilmington | | W | | 12-5 | | Walsh* | | W | | 7-2 | | Walsh* | | W | | 12-6 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 1-8 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 2-9 | | Urbana* | | W | | 11-7 | | Urbana* | | W | | 10-5 | | NCCAA District III Tournament | | Mount Vernon Nazarene | | L | | 2-5 | | Indiana Wesleyan | | W | | 7-2 | | Grace (forfeit) | | W | | 7-0 | | Spring Arbor | | W | | 13-10 | | | 1993 - Head Coach: Kathy Freese | | 13-22 (.371) Overall; 4-10 (.286) MOC* | | Morningside | | L | | 4-9 | | East Central | | L | | 3-4 | | Knox | | W | | 5-4 | | Knox | | L | | 10-11 | | Capital | | L | | 1-4 | | Wisconsin Lutheran | | W | | 4-1 | | Adrian | | L | | 0-3 | | Albion | | W | | 4-2 | | Grace | | L | | 2-11 | | Wilmington | | W | | 8-0 | | Wilmington | | W | | 1-0 | | Mount St. Joseph | | W | | 1-0 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 1-2 | | Ohio Dominican* | | W | | 11-6 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 1-13 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 0-6 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 1-7 | | Rio Grande* | | L | | 2-5 | | Rio Grande* | | W | | 13-3 | | Urbana* | | W | | 5-3 | | Urbana* | | L | | 2-7 | | Walsh* | | L | | 1-2 | | Walsh* (9 inn.) | | W | | 7-6 | | Wittenberg | | L | | 2-3 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 5-2 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 1-3 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 7-12 | | NCCAA District III Tournament | | Spring Arbor | | L | | 2-6 | | Oakland City | | W | | 7-4 | | Grace | | L | | 1-9 | | Indiana Wesleyan | | L | | 0-5 | | | | | | | | Tiffin* | | L | | 4-6 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 5-6 | | Findlay | | L | | 2-6 | | Findlay | | W | | 3-2 | |
| | |
| 1994 - Head Coach: Kathy Freese | | 9-26 (.257) Overall; 2-12 (.143) MOC* | | Lincoln | | W | | 6-4 | | Bluefield State | | L | | 4-7 | | William Jewel | | L | | 3-4 | | William Jewel | | L | | 4-10 | | Urbana | | L | | 8-10 | | Urbana | | L | | 17-19 | | Marian | | L | | 4-5 | | Tri-State | | L | | 3-6 | | Trinity Christian | | W | | 14-13 | | St. Francis IN | | L | | 3-9 | | Olivet Nazarene | | L | | 14-15 | | Wilmington | | W | | 15-1 | | Wilmington | | L | | 1-9 | | Rio Grande* | | L | | 2-4 | | Rio Grande* | | L | | 4-15 | | Urbana* | | L | | 7-9 | | Urbana* | | L | | 1-25 | | Findlay | | W | | 7-6 | | Findlay | | L | | 6-16 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 1-9 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 4-17 | | Malone | | W | | 3-1 | | Malone | | W | | 10-6 | | Ohio Dominican* | | W | | 4-3 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 13-21 | | Walsh* | | L | | 1-4 | | Walsh* | | L | | 5-12 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 1-4 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 1-17 | | Mount Vernon Naz.* (9 inn.) | | W | | 13-11 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 6-20 | | Shawnee State* (8 inn.) | | L | | 3-5 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 1-11 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 6-3 | | Wittenberg | | L | | 3-7 | | | 1995 - Head Coach: Kathy Freese | | 17-24 (.415) Overall; 8-10 (.444) MOC* | | William Woods (8 inn.) | | L | | 4-5 | | William Woods | | L | | 0-8 | | Cumberland KY | | W | | 2-1 | | Tennessee Wesleyan | | L | | 7-8 | | Bellarmine | | W | | 5-3 | | Columbia | | L | | 1-7 | | Bluefield State | | W | | 4-1 | | Mobile | | L | | 0-8 | | William Woods (9 inn.) | | L | | 5-6 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 2-3 | | Mount St. Joseph (8 inn.) | | L | | 1-2 | | Wilmington | | L | | 4-6 | | Wilmington | | L | | 4-6 | | Urbana | | W | | 9-0 | | Urbana | | L | | 1-2 | | Malone* | | W | | 7-5 | | Malone* (8 inn.) | | L | | 5-6 | | Tiffin* | | W | | 8-0 | | Tiffin* (8 inn.) | | L | | 6-7 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 4-6 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 2-13 | | Urbana* | | W | | 5-1 | | Urbana* | | L | | 5-6 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 0-5 | | Ohio Dominican* (8 inn.) | | W | | 6-5 | | Rio Grande* | | W | | 3-1 | | Rio Grande* | | L | | 2-7 | | NCCAA District III Tournament | | Indiana Wesleyan | | L | | 4-6 | | Taylor | | W | | 17-8 | | Concordia (forfeit) | | W | | 7-0 | | | | | | | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 0-9 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 0-5 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 5-3 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 3-0 | | Walsh* | | W | | 5-1 | | Walsh* | | L | | 0-7 | | Findlay* | | W | | 4-1 | | Findlay* | | W | | 17-1 | | | | | | | | Mid-Ohio Conference Tournament | | Malone | | L | | 3-5 | | Rio Grande | | W | | 13-4 | | Tiffin | | L | | 0-2 | |
| | |
| 1996 - Head Coach: Joy Fagan | | 19-20-1 (.488) Overall; 10-5-1 (.656) MOC* | | Bethel MN | | W | | 4-0 | | Bethel MN | | W | | 4-3 | | Central Methodist | | L | | 14-20 | | Cumberland KY | | L | | 5-8 | | Mobile | | L | | 1-7 | | Mobile | | L | | 0-8 | | Southern California College | | W | | 6-5 | | Central Methodist | | L | | 9-10 | | Shawnee State | | L | | 6-17 | | Urbana | | W | | 4-1 | | Urbana | | L | | 2-7 | | Walsh* | | W | | 2-1 | | Walsh* | | T | | 12-12 | | Findlay* | | W | | 7-6 | | Findlay* | | W | | 7-2 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 9-10 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | W | | 4-3 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 4-5 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 1-3 | | Rio Grande* | | L | | 3-4 | | Rio Grande* (8 inn.) | | W | | 7-6 | | Malone* | | W | | 17-7 | | Malone* | | W | | 12-4 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 1-7 | | Ohio Dominican* (11 inn.) | | W | | 9-8 | | Urbana* | | W | | 6-5 | | Urbana* | | W | | 8-2 | | NCCAA District III Tournament | | Oakland City | | W | | 4-1 | | Concordia (8 inn.) | | W | | 4-3 | | Spring Arbor | | L | | 1-3 | | Concordia | | L | | 2-6 | | NCCAA National Tournament | | Olivet Nazarene | | L | | 1-3 | | Bethel IN | | L | | 5-15 | | Lee | | L | | 1-2 | | Greenville | | W | | 2-1 | | Lee | | L | | 0-15 | | Mid-Ohio Conference Tournament | | Tiffin | | W | | 7-5 | | Shawnee State | | L | | 0-7 | | Tiffin | | W | | 4-1 | | Shawnee State | | L | | 0-4 | | | 1997 - Head Coach: Dave Gaffner | | 9-24 (.273) Overall; 4-14 (.222) MOC* | | Belhaven | | L | | 5-7 | | Huntingdon | | L | | 3-5 | | William Carey | | L | | 2-8 | | Belhaven | | W | | 9-1 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 7-8 | | Ohio Dominican* (forfeit) | | L | | 0-7 | | Urbana | | L | | 0-8 | | Urbana | | L | | 2-10 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | W | | 2-1 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 4-6 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 0-13 | | Tiffin* (8 inn.) | | L | | 3-5 | | Findlay* | | L | | 4-10 | | Rio Grande* | | W | | 9-4 | | Rio Grande* | | W | | 8-7 | | Urbana* | | L | | 0-2 | | Urbana* | | L | | 3-8 | | Walsh* | | L | | 0-1 | | Walsh* | | L | | 1-7 | | Malone* | | L | | 0-3 | | Malone* | | W | | 4-0 | | Findlay* | | L | | 0-8 | | Findlay | | W | | 3-2 | | Wittenberg | | L | | 0-3 | | Wittenberg | | L | | 9-11 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 1-4 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 2-12 | | Wilmington | | W | | 8-6 | | Wilmington | | W | | 3-1 | | Taylor | | W | | 4-3 | | Taylor | | L | | 7-8 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 6-9 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 1-7 | |
| | |
| 1998 - Head Coach: Dave Gaffner | | 4-21 (.160) Overall; 1-15 (.063) MOC* | | Southeastern Oklahoma | | L | | 1-5 | | Mobile | | L | | 0-9 | | Houston Baptist | | L | | 0-11 | | Southern Wesleyan | | L | | 3-5 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 7-27 | | Ohio Dominican* (8 inn.) | | L | | 5-6 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 2-5 | | Mount Vernon Naz.* (9 inn.) | | W | | 7-5 | | Walsh* | | L | | 0-5 | | Walsh* | | L | | 5-10 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 2-3 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 0-2 | | Urbana* | | L | | 2-10 | | Urbana* | | L | | 3-9 | | Malone* | | L | | 1-3 | | Malone* | | L | | 3-6 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 1-6 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 1-12 | | Urbana | | L | | 1-10 | | Urbana | | W | | 8-2 | | Taylor | | L | | 2-5 | | Rio Grande* | | L | | 1-4 | | Rio Grande* | | L | | 3-5 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 4-0 | | Wittenberg | | W | | 6-2 | | | 1999 - Head Coach: Jim Irish | | 9-29 (.237) Overall; 7-15 (.318) AMC* | | Athens State | | L | | 0-6 | | Athens State | | L | | 0-8 | | Faulkner | | L | | 0-8 | | Faulkner | | L | | 1-9 | | Houston Baptist | | L | | 0-7 | | Mobile | | L | | 0-9 | | Faulkner | | L | | 0-8 | | Houston Baptist | | L | | 1-9 | | LaGrange | | W | | 4-1 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 0-12 | | Mount St. Joseph | | L | | 7-8 | | Urbana* | | L | | 5-8 | | Urbana* | | L | | 9-10 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | L | | 1-4 | | Mount Vernon Nazarene* | | W | | 4-3 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 8-11 | | Ohio Dominican* | | L | | 2-10 | | Rio Grande* | | L | | 7-11 | | Rio Grande* | | W | | 6-5 | | Saint Vincent* | | W | | 11-1 | | Saint Vincent* | | W | | 18-9 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 2-3 | | Tiffin* | | L | | 3-9 | | Wittenberg | | L | | 1-2 | | Wittenberg | | L | | 1-4 | | Walsh* | | L | | 0-9 | | Walsh* | | L | | 5-9 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 2-6 | | Shawnee State* | | L | | 0-9 | | NCCAA Midwest Regional | | Grace | | L | | 4-6 | | | | | | | | Geneva* | | W | | 8-7 | | Geneva* | | L | | 0-8 | | Notre Dame OH* | | W | | 8-4 | | Notre Dame OH* | | W | | 10-5 | | Malone* | | L | | 3-11 | | Malone* | | L | | 3-14 | | Taylor | | W | | 6-1 | | Taylor | | L | | 5-13 | |