| Year | | Host | | Individual Champion | | Team Champion |
| 1973 | | Baptist Bible PA | | Dave Billings (Nyack) | | Eastern Mennonite |
| 1974 | | Bryan College | | Dave Billings (Nyack) | | Eastern Mennonite |
| 1975 | | Grace College | | Steve Oswald (Grand Rapids) | | Bryan |
| 1976 | | Grace College | | Ken Layman (Eastern Mennonite) | | Eastern Mennonite |
| 1977 | | Baptist Bible PA | | Ken Layman (Eastern Mennonite) | | Eastern Mennonite |
| 1978 | | Cedarville College | | Dale Shaw (Cedarville) | | Cedarville |
| 1979 | | Cedarville College | | John Foss (Marion) | | Cedarville |
| 1980 | | Cedarville College | | Brad Erikstad (LeTourneau) | | Anderson |
| 1981 | | Cedarville College | | John Foss (Marion) | | Anderson |
| 1982 | | Cedarville College | | John Foss (Marion) | | Anderson |
| 1983 | | Cedarville College | | Matt Pearson (John Brown) | | Anderson |
| 1984 | | Cedarville College | | Matt Pearson (John Brown) | | Anderson |
| 1985 | | Cedarville College | | Brian Williams (Anderson) | | Cedarville |
| 1986 | | Cedarville College | | Brian Williams (Anderson) | | Malone |
| 1987 | | Cedarville College | | Eric Fillinger (Cedarville) | | Malone |
| 1988 | | Cedarville College | | Eric Fillinger (Cedarville) | | Malone |
| 1989 | | Cedarville College | | Eric Fillinger (Cedarville) | | Malone |
| 1990 | | Cedarville College | | Ira Wentworth (Malone | | Malone |
| 1991 | | Cedarville College | | John Murray (Malone) | | Malone |
| 1992 | | Cedarville College | | Eddie Harris (Malone) | | Malone |
| 1993 | | Roberts Wesleyan College | | Geoffrey Rono (Roberts Wesleyan) | | Roberts Wesleyan |
| 1994 | | Roberts Wesleyan College | | P.J. O'Rourke (Malone) | | Malone |
| 1995 | | Cedarville College | | James Njoroge (Taylor) | | Malone |
| 1996 | | Cedarville College | | James Njoroge (Taylor) | | Malone |
| 1997 | | Cedarville College | | Gareth Wilford (Cumberland) | | Taylor |
| 1998 | | Cedarville College | | Kip Rop (Taylor) | | Malone |
| 1999 | | Cedarville College | | James Kennedy (Grace) | | Malone |
| 2000 | | Cedarville University | | Dave Leonard (Malone) | | Malone |
| 2001 | | Cedarville University | | Daniel Kibungei, Malone | | Northwest Nazarene |
| 2002 | | Cedarville University | | Sergio Reyes (Cedarville) | | Malone |
| 2003 | | Cedarville University | | Herbert Rotich (Spring Arbor) | | Malone |
| 2004 | | Cedarville University | | Leo Kormanik (Malone) | | MidAmerica Nazarene |
| 2005 | | Cedarville University | | Julius Rono (Roberts Wesleyan) | | Malone |
