| Year | | Host | | Individual Champion | | Team Champion |
| 1981 | | Cedarville College | | Kim Southworth (Spring Arbor) | | Spring Arbor |
| 1982 | | Cedarville College | | Lois Lundy (Anderson) | | Spring Arbor |
| 1983 | | Cedarville College | | Lois Lundy (Anderson) | | Anderson |
| 1984 | | Cedarville College | | Jane Romig (Cedarville) | | Anderson |
| 1985 | | Cedarville College | | Jane Romig (Cedarville) | | Cedarville |
| 1986 | | Cedarville College | | Marguerite Skello (Malone) | | Malone |
| 1987 | | Cedarville College | | Marguerite Skello (Malone) | | Malone |
| 1988 | | Cedarville College | | Jill Jamison (George Fox) | | George Fox |
| 1989 | | Cedarville College | | Melanie Bingham (Anderson) | | Malone |
| 1990 | | Cedarville College | | Valerie Bingham (Anderson) | | Malone |
| 1991 | | Cedarville College | | Julie Ferguson (Malone) | | Cedarville |
| 1992 | | Cedarville College | | Krista Pritchard (Cedarville) | | Malone |
| 1993 | | Roberts Wesleyan College | | Naomi Fruchey (Taylor) | | Malone |
| 1994 | | Roberts Wesleyan College | | Michelle Burson (Cedarville) | | Olivet Nazarene |
| 1995 | | Cedarville College | | Jenny Kohl (Olivet Nazarene) | | Olivet Nazarene |
| 1996 | | Cedarville College | | Julianne Pletcher (Cedarville) | | Cedarville |
| 1997 | | Cedarville College | | Brittany Riggins (Cumberland) | | Malone |
| 1998 | | Cedarville College | | Gigi Hopple (Malone) | | Malone |
| 1999 | | Cedarville College | | Everlyne Lagat (Malone) | | Malone |
| 2000 | | Cedarville University | | Missy Almond (Malone) | | Spring Arbor |
| 2001 | | Cedarville University | | Erin Nehus (Cedarville) | | Cedarville |
| 2002 | | Cedarville University | | Jennifer Tetrick (Cedarville) | | Cedarville |
| 2003 | | Cedarville University | | Lacey Watkins (Malone) | | Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2004 | | Cedarville University | | Lacey Watkins (Malone) | | Malone |
| 2005 | | Cedarville University | | Joanna Genter (Malone) | | Malone |
